There can be no question of the fact that Slowdive's second album, Souvlaki, is probably the best album of all time of the week, the year, the 90s and the history of recorded music (at least tied with Loveless; Isn't Anything preferrers go be tryhards somewhere else). Nor can there be much question that Pygmalion was an audacious change of pace and a respectable, tasteful hipster fave, nor even that their later works make excellent use of the possibilities of more recent production techniques. If you play Just For A Day and Souvlaki back to back, not a jury in the land would convict Souvlaki of anything less than a brutal murder of the OG effort, nor could I endeavour in good conscience to appeal the verdict as anything but just.
But I like Just For A Day, because it is so pure in concept and because it blew my tiny mind upon first hearing it, and no man can but fondly and wistfully recall the first such blowing he received. Souvlaki is, unquestionably, the better collection of songs, somehow more pop and more sophisticated and more audacious at once. You'd have to call in a certified caprinologist to review it; I just know a GOAT when I see one. "Souvlaki Space Station" is weird, "Alison" sublime, and "Dagger" brilliantly jarring in its waking to regretful recollection from the dreampop haze.
But Just For A Day plays like variations on a theme, its noisy swells elemental, oceanic, like waves pounding inexorably, crushingly, yet gracefully, upon a sullen and deserted shore, and after each such surge recedes it leaves those swirling eddies in the crevices and rock pools in its wake. In opener "Spanish Air" Halstead opines "I long for the sun, the wind and rain". By "Waves" his wish, and life, has been fulfilled: it "felt so good to see the sun". The whole album evokes a long and solitary walk along an overcast beach in the liminal seasons of spring and autumn; melancholy, calm and elation all flowing in and out of one another like a tide. It's music by which to contemplate eternity.
